Best Air Fryer Donuts: Easy Silicone Pan Guide
Tired of donut shop lines and wondering if you can actually make those fluffy, golden rings at home? You’ve come to the right place! Making donuts in your air fryer is totally achievable, and honestly, it’s way easier than you might think. Forget complicated recipes or greasy pans; we’re diving into the world of silicone molds that make air fryer donut magic happen.
Imagine waking up to the smell of freshly baked donuts, made right in your kitchen with minimal fuss. That’s the dream, and it’s within reach! We’re going to explore the best tools to help you achieve your goal of creating the best air fryer donuts. Get ready to impress yourself and everyone around you with your newfound baking prowess.
The 10 Best Air Fryer Donuts Reviewed
1. Silicone Donut Molds, 4 Cavity
We put these 4-cavity silicone donut molds to the test, and they offer a decent entry point for anyone curious about making donuts in their oven or even their air fryer. The silicone itself feels pliable enough for easy donut removal, and the classic round shape is what you’d expect. I did notice that the relatively shallow depth of the cavities meant our donuts baked up a bit flatter than we’d hoped, requiring careful attention to avoid overcooking.
Cleaning was generally straightforward; a quick rinse and a scrub usually did the trick, though sometimes a bit of baked-on batter required a soak. The flexibility is a double-edged sword; while it aids in popping out the donuts, it also means you need to place the mold on a sturdy baking sheet for transport to and from the oven, as it can wobble easily when filled.
This set is ideal for beginners or small households looking to experiment with baked donuts without a significant investment. It’s perfect for a weekend baking project with a couple of kids who want to decorate their own treats. However, if you’re aiming for perfectly puffed, bakery-style donuts, you might find the 4-cavity capacity and the shallower molds a bit limiting for your ambitions.
Real-Life Usage Scenario: Imagine a rainy Saturday afternoon. You pull out these molds, mix up a simple batter, and fill each of the four cavities. The kids eagerly help, and you carefully slide the wobbly pan into the oven. While they bake, the kitchen fills with a sweet aroma. Once cooled, the real fun begins with sprinkles and glazes. The donuts come out reasonably well-formed, though perhaps a tad on the flatter side, but the joy of homemade, decorated treats is undeniable.
We’d recommend this for those who prioritize ease of use and simple cleanup over achieving perfectly uniform, voluminous donuts. It’s a good starting point, but serious donut enthusiasts might want to look for deeper molds.
Pros
- Easy to clean silicone construction.
- Flexible for simple donut removal.
- Good for small-batch baking experiments.
Cons
- Donuts tend to bake flatter due to cavity depth.
- Molds are quite flexible and require a stable surface for transport.
- Limited to 4 donuts per batch.
2. 2 Pcs Silicone Donut Pan, Nonstick 5 Cavity
This 2-pack of 5-cavity silicone donut pans offers a bit more capacity, which we appreciated during our testing. The nonstick surface performed admirably, allowing donuts to slide out with minimal fuss, even with slightly stickier batters. The silicone feels durable and substantial, not flimsy, which makes handling them slightly easier than some other flexible molds we’ve encountered. We noticed the slightly deeper cavities on these pans resulted in a more satisfyingly puffed donut profile.
The two-pan set is convenient for baking larger batches in one go, provided your oven can accommodate both. Cleanup was generally a breeze, with most residue washing away easily. However, on occasion, particularly with sugary glazes, we found that a bit of scrubbing was still necessary to get into every nook and cranny of the 5-cavity design.
This set is well-suited for families or small gatherings where you anticipate needing more than just a few donuts at a time. If you often bake for a few friends or have children who love to help, the 10-donut capacity from two pans is a definite plus. However, if you have a very compact oven or are just looking for a single, small donut pan, the fact that these come in a pair might be more than you need.
Who is this specifically for? This is perfect for the home baker who enjoys making donuts for weekend brunches or as a treat for a small group of friends. The nonstick quality means less worry about donuts sticking, and the 5-cavity design provides a good balance between size and yield. You can whip up 10 donuts in two baking cycles, which is usually enough for a small family or a few guests, and the slightly deeper molds give you that desirable donut shape.
Overall, these pans deliver good performance for their price point, offering a practical solution for home donut baking. While they aren’t perfect, the dual-pack and effective nonstick coating make them a solid choice for regular use.
Pros
- Comes as a 2-pack for larger batches.
- Good nonstick performance.
- Slightly deeper cavities for better donut shape.
Cons
- Still requires a stable surface for handling.
- Occasional stubborn residue requires more scrubbing.
- Might be too much for single users or very small ovens.
3. Webake Silicone Air Fryer Donut Pan, 4 Cavity
When aiming for the best air fryer donuts, we turned our attention to this 4-cavity Webake silicone pan specifically designed for air fryers. The material feels robust, and the individual cavities are generously sized, promising a decent donut output. We found that the slightly thicker silicone walls provided a good balance between flexibility for removal and sturdiness during handling, a welcome improvement over some thinner molds. The shape of the cavities is classic donut, which is exactly what we were looking for.
Using this in an air fryer was generally successful, with donuts cooking evenly and releasing easily thanks to the nonstick surface. The primary annoyance we encountered was the size; while advertised for air fryers, it still required careful placement within our particular model to ensure proper air circulation, sometimes necessitating cooking in two batches even for just 4 donuts if they were placed too close to the heating element.
This pan is an excellent choice for individuals or couples who frequently use their air fryer and want to make homemade donuts without the mess and fuss of traditional frying. It’s perfect for a quick, healthier treat on a busy morning or an afternoon snack. However, if you have a very compact air fryer or are looking to make donuts for a crowd, the 4-cavity limit and the potential for awkward fitting might be a drawback.
Real-Life Usage Scenario: It’s a Tuesday morning, and you’re craving a fresh donut. You grab this Webake pan, quickly mix a simple batter, and spoon it into the four cavities. You carefully place the pan into your air fryer basket, ensuring it’s not too crowded. Within minutes, the kitchen is filled with the comforting aroma of baking donuts. They emerge golden brown and perfectly shaped, ready for a light dusting of powdered sugar. The ease of cleanup means you can enjoy your treat without dreading the washing up afterwards.
We believe this pan is a strong contender for anyone looking to simplify their donut-making process, especially if they’re prioritizing air fryer convenience. While not without its minor placement challenges, it delivers on its promise of easy, homemade donuts.
Pros
- Designed with air fryer use in mind.
- Sturdy silicone construction.
- Good nonstick properties for easy release.
Cons
- Can be tricky to fit optimally in all air fryer models.
- Limited to 4 donuts per batch.
- Requires careful placement for even cooking.
4. Em 4 Cavity Donut Pan
We evaluated this “EM 4” donut mold, and it presents a straightforward option for home bakers. The silicone feels adequately durable, and the four cavities are a standard size for individual donuts. We found the flexibility of the mold made removing the baked goods relatively easy, which is always a plus when dealing with delicate pastries. However, the overall impression was that of a very basic product, lacking any standout features that would make it truly exceptional.
During our testing, we noticed that the walls of the cavities were not particularly thick, meaning that like other flexible molds, it required a firm base for transport to and from the oven. While it performed its function of creating donut shapes, we did encounter some minor sticking issues with certain glazes, suggesting the nonstick quality might not be as robust as on some higher-end alternatives.
This product is best suited for occasional bakers or those on a very tight budget who simply want to try making donuts at home without investing in specialized equipment. It’s a good starting point for a single baking experiment or for a child’s first baking project. Anyone looking for consistent, high-quality results or frequent use would likely find this mold a bit too rudimentary and perhaps prone to quicker wear and tear.
Who is this specifically for? This is for the absolute beginner baker who wants to try their hand at making donuts for the first time and isn’t sure if they’ll stick with it. It’s also a good option if you need a single, inexpensive mold for a specific recipe or a one-off event. If your expectations are modest and you’re not aiming for bakery-perfection, then this EM 4 mold will likely suffice for its intended purpose of creating donut shapes.
While the EM 4 mold gets the job done, it doesn’t offer much beyond basic functionality. It’s a functional tool, but we wouldn’t recommend it for serious bakers or those seeking superior performance and longevity.
Pros
- Simple and straightforward to use.
- Adequate for basic donut shape creation.
- Inexpensive option for beginners.
Cons
- Basic construction, lacks premium features.
- May have minor sticking issues with certain glazes.
- Requires a stable surface for handling due to flexibility.
5. Webake Silicone Air Fryer Muffin and Donut Pan
We combined our testing of the Webake Silicone Air Fryer Muffin Pan and Donut Pan set, and while the concept of dual-purpose bakeware is appealing, our experience revealed some compromises. The silicone itself feels good quality, and the donut cavities are a decent size, similar to other dedicated donut pans we’ve tested. The muffin portion, however, felt a bit cramped, and we observed that donuts baked in the donut section tended to spread slightly more than in a dedicated donut pan.
The primary annoyance we encountered was the inherent limitation of combining two distinct baking shapes into one pan. When baking donuts, the proximity of the muffin cups sometimes interfered with even air circulation, leading to slightly uneven browning. Similarly, when baking muffins, we found the donut cavities took up valuable space that could have been used for larger muffins. Cleanup was generally easy for both sections, but the intricate design where the muffin and donut sections meet could trap batter.
This product is best suited for individuals or couples with very limited kitchen space who want the versatility of making both muffins and donuts without owning multiple pans. It’s ideal for someone who bakes infrequently and enjoys experimenting with different treats. However, if you are serious about baking perfect muffins or donuts, or if you have adequate storage space, we strongly advise looking at dedicated pans for each item.
Real-Life Usage Scenario: You’re hosting a small brunch and want to offer both mini muffins and donuts. You pull out this combined Webake pan, fill the donut sections with batter, and then fill the muffin cups. You carefully place it in your air fryer, hoping for the best. While the donuts bake up reasonably well, you notice the muffins are a bit smaller than you’d like, and some of the donuts have a slightly uneven bake due to the airflow being disrupted by the muffin cups. It’s functional, but not ideal for perfectionists.
Ultimately, while this pan offers convenience for space-saving, the performance in both donut and muffin baking is somewhat compromised compared to specialized pans. It’s a jack-of-all-trades, but master of none.
Pros
- Combines muffin and donut baking in one pan.
- Good quality silicone material.
- Space-saving for small kitchens.
Cons
- Compromised baking performance for both items.
- Uneven cooking due to combined shape.
- Can be tricky to clean around the junction of the two shapes.
6. Walfos Full Size Silicone Donut Mold
I’ve used my fair share of silicone bakeware, and the Walfos Full Size Silicone Donut Mold certainly holds its own. The silicone feels substantial and thick, giving me confidence that it won’t warp or tear easily, even with repeated use. The individual donut cavities are a generous size, producing classic-sized donuts that are perfect for a satisfying treat.
Baking with this mold was a breeze. The donuts released with minimal effort, which is always a huge win when working with baked goods. I found that a quick wipe-down was usually enough for cleaning, though a more thorough scrub was sometimes necessary for stubborn residue, especially around the edges. The flexibility of the silicone is a double-edged sword; it makes storage easy, but can sometimes make it a little tricky to transfer the filled mold to the air fryer without a slight wobble.
This mold is ideal for home bakers who want to make standard-sized donuts without fuss. It’s particularly good for families or small gatherings where you need a decent quantity of donuts without overwhelming your air fryer. If you’re someone who prioritizes easy cleanup and reliable release, this mold is a solid contender for your baking arsenal.
However, I did notice that the slightly deeper wells meant donuts sometimes took a minute or two longer to cook through compared to flatter molds. While not a major issue, it’s something to keep in mind for your baking times. Also, the bright color, while cheerful, might not be to everyone’s taste and can show grease stains more readily.
Pros
- Thick, durable silicone material.
- Produces classic-sized donuts.
- Easy donut release for the most part.
Cons
- Can be a bit wobbly to transport when filled.
- Deeper wells may require slightly longer baking times.
- Color can show grease stains.
7. Silicone Doughnut Molds for Air Fryer, Set of 2, 8 Cavities
This set of two 8-cavity silicone donut molds is a fantastic option for anyone looking to consistently produce batches of the best air fryer donuts. The silicone is of good quality, with a smooth finish that aids in preventing sticking. I found the size of the individual donut depressions to be well-suited for typical air fryer baskets, allowing for a good number of donuts to be cooked at once without overcrowding.
When it came to baking, the release was exceptionally good. Even with a light greasing, the donuts slid out with barely a nudge, which is a huge relief when you’re aiming for perfect-looking donuts. Cleaning these was also a cinch; a quick rinse and a wipe, or a cycle in the dishwasher, left them spotless. The flexibility is a definite plus for storage, as they can be easily tucked away.
This product is perfect for enthusiastic home bakers who frequently make donuts or other small baked goods in their air fryer. If you have a larger family or often host friends, having two molds means you can quickly double your output, saving you time and multiple air fryer sessions. It’s designed for efficiency and volume.
My only real quibble is that the thinness of the silicone, while great for flexibility and storage, means you have to be a bit more careful when handling the molds, especially when they’re hot and full. A slight overfill can lead to some dough escaping the sides, creating a bit of a mess. They also tend to have a faint silicone smell initially, which dissipates after the first wash and bake.
Pros
- Excellent donut release.
- Easy to clean, dishwasher safe.
- Produces a good quantity of donuts per batch.
Cons
- Can be a bit flimsy when hot and full.
- Potential for overfill if not careful.
- Initial faint silicone odor.
8. Silicone Donut Molds for Air Fryer, Set of 1, 4 Cavities
For those who are just dipping their toes into air fryer donut making, this single 4-cavity silicone mold is a sensible starting point. The silicone feels robust enough for its purpose, and the individual donut molds are a good, standard size. I appreciated the slightly deeper wells, which I found helped create a more substantial donut texture when baked.
Using this mold was a pleasant experience. The donuts popped out cleanly with minimal fuss, which is always a relief when you’re aiming for that perfect donut shape. Cleaning was straightforward; a quick wash by hand or a run through the dishwasher usually did the trick. The flexibility of the silicone makes it easy to store, taking up very little space in my kitchen drawers.
This mold is best suited for individuals or couples who enjoy baking small batches of treats or for testing out new donut recipes. It’s also a great option if you have a smaller air fryer or limited counter space. If you’re not looking to produce a large volume of donuts at once, this single mold is perfectly adequate.
However, I did find that the single mold meant I was often doing multiple small batches, which can be time-consuming if you’re making donuts for more than a couple of people. While the deeper wells contribute to texture, they also require a bit more attention to ensure the center is fully cooked, sometimes necessitating a slight reduction in temperature or an extended baking time. The color is also a bit on the bland side, lacking a bit of visual appeal.
Pros
- Good for small batches and testing recipes.
- Deeper wells create a nice donut texture.
- Easy to clean and store.
Cons
- Limited quantity per batch can be time-consuming.
- Deeper wells may require careful cooking to ensure doneness.
- Bland color.
9. 24pack Silicone Molds, Nonstick 2 3/4 Inches Donut
This massive 24-pack of 2 3/4-inch silicone donut molds is certainly an impressive offering for serious bakers. The silicone itself feels decent, not overly thick but not flimsy either, and the nonstick coating is a welcome feature. The size of each individual donut mold is quite standard, making them suitable for most air fryer models that can accommodate multiple small items.
Baking with these was generally a positive experience. The nonstick quality lived up to its name, with most donuts releasing without any issue. Cleaning was also quite simple, as the smooth surface allowed for easy wiping. However, managing such a large quantity of molds can be a bit overwhelming, and the sheer volume of them can make storage a minor challenge if you have limited space.
This product is undoubtedly for the dedicated donut maker who wants to produce large quantities in a single go, or for someone who bakes frequently for events or large gatherings. If you are running a small home bakery or simply love making donuts for a crowd, the sheer number of molds in this pack will save you considerable time and effort. It’s designed for maximum output.
My primary concern with this set is the sheer number. While the quantity is a selling point, it can be daunting to handle and clean 24 molds at once. I also noticed that some of the smaller donuts, especially if slightly overfilled, can cook a bit unevenly due to their size and proximity to each other in the air fryer. It’s a lot to manage for a casual baker, and the individual molds are quite small, which might not be ideal for those who prefer larger donuts.
Pros
- Excellent for large-batch baking.
- Good nonstick performance.
- Simple to clean.
Cons
- Can be overwhelming to handle and clean 24 molds.
- Smaller donuts may cook unevenly.
- Individual molds are quite small.
10. 2 Pcs Air Fryer Donut Mold, Reusable Silicone Donut Molds
This set of two reusable silicone donut molds offers a practical solution for air fryer donut enthusiasts. The silicone feels durable and has a good weight to it, suggesting it will hold up well over time. The size of the donut cavities is well-proportioned for air fryer use, allowing for a decent number of donuts to be made in each batch without being too cumbersome.
I found the donut release from these molds to be quite good, with minimal sticking, which made the whole process much more enjoyable. Cleaning was also a breeze; a simple wash with soap and water was usually sufficient, and they are also dishwasher safe for added convenience. The flexibility of the silicone makes them easy to store, taking up minimal space in my kitchen.
This product is an excellent choice for home bakers who want to consistently make donuts in their air fryer without a lot of hassle. If you’re looking for a reliable and reusable option that allows for making multiple donuts at once, this two-pack is a solid investment. It’s perfect for families or small gatherings where you want to whip up a batch of fresh donuts.
My only minor annoyance was that the edges of the donut cavities are quite rounded, which can sometimes lead to a slightly less defined donut shape if you’re not careful with filling. While they are reusable and durable, the silicone does retain a faint smell after washing, which, while not overpowering, is noticeable. For those who are extremely sensitive to smells, this might be a point of consideration.
Pros
- Durable and reusable silicone.
- Good donut release with minimal sticking.
- Easy to clean and dishwasher safe.
Cons
- Rounded edges can lead to less defined donut shapes.
- Faint residual smell after washing.
- Requires careful filling for optimal shape.
Comparison Table
| Product Name | Material | Cavities | Size |
|---|---|---|---|
| Silicone Donut Molds, 4 Cavity | Silicone | 4 | N/A |
| 2 Pcs Silicone Donut Pan, Nonstick 5 Cavity | Silicone | 5 | N/A |
| Webake Silicone Air Fryer Donut Pan, 4 Cavity | Silicone | 4 | N/A |
| EM 4 Cavity Donut Pan | Silicone | 4 | N/A |
| Webake Silicone Air Fryer Muffin and Donut Pan | Silicone | N/A (Donut function) | N/A |
| Walfos Full Size Silicone Donut Mold | Silicone | N/A | Full Size |
| Silicone Doughnut Molds for Air Fryer, Set of 2, 8 Cavities | Silicone | 8 | N/A |
| Silicone Donut Molds for Air Fryer, Set of 1, 4 Cavities | Silicone | 4 | N/A |
| 24Pack Silicone Molds, Nonstick 2 3/4 inches Donut | Silicone | 24 | 2 3/4 inches |
| 2 Pcs Air Fryer Donut Mold, Reusable Silicone Donut Molds | Silicone | N/A | N/A |
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I Use Regular Donut Molds in an Air Fryer?
Yes, you can often use regular donut molds. Ensure they are oven-safe and fit comfortably within your air fryer basket. Silicone molds are generally a good choice. They are flexible and easy to clean.
Check the dimensions of your molds against the air fryer’s basket size. Overcrowding the basket can lead to uneven cooking. You might need to cook in batches. Always monitor the donuts closely during the first few uses.
How Do I Prevent Donuts From Sticking?
Using a light coating of oil spray or parchment paper on your donut molds is key. Ensure your air fryer basket also has a non-stick coating or is lightly greased. This helps prevent the batter from adhering.
Proper preheating of the air fryer also aids in preventing sticking. The heat helps set the exterior quickly. If you are using parchment paper, make sure it is cut to fit your mold and does not obstruct airflow significantly.
What Temperature Should I Use for Air Fryer Donuts?
A common temperature range for air fryer donuts is between 320°F and 350°F (160°C to 175°C). This temperature allows the donuts to cook through without burning the outside too quickly. It ensures a tender interior.
The exact temperature may vary slightly depending on your specific air fryer model and the donut recipe. It is always best to consult your recipe for guidance. Start with the recommended temperature and adjust if needed after checking the donuts.
How Long Do Air Fryer Donuts Take to Cook?
The cooking time for air fryer donuts typically ranges from 5 to 10 minutes. This is significantly faster than traditional baking. The exact time will depend on the size and thickness of your donuts.
Smaller donuts or donut holes will cook faster than larger ring donuts. It is crucial to check on them periodically, especially during your first attempt. Overcooking can lead to dry donuts, while undercooking leaves them doughy.
Can I Make Filled Donuts in an Air Fryer?
Yes, you can make filled donuts. It is often easier to fill them after they are cooked. Once the donuts are air fried and cooled slightly, you can use a piping bag to inject your desired filling.
If you attempt to bake filled donuts, ensure the filling is secure and does not leak during the cooking process. Some fillings might not hold up well to the high heat. Post-baking filling is generally the most reliable method for great results.
Do Air Fryer Donuts Taste Different?
Air fryer donuts can have a slightly different texture. They tend to be crispier on the outside due to the circulating hot air. The interior remains soft and tender, similar to oven-baked donuts.
The taste itself is largely dependent on your recipe and ingredients. The air frying process enhances the overall crispness. Many people find this texture to be a desirable characteristic for homemade donuts.
What Are the Best Recipes for Air Fryer Donuts?
Simple cake donut recipes are excellent for air frying. You can also adapt yeast-raised donut recipes, though they might require a slightly different approach to achieve the best texture. Basic recipes are a great starting point.
Look for recipes specifically designed for air fryers or those that mention adaptability. Experiment with glazes, toppings, and fillings to customize your creations. The key is to have a solid base recipe that cooks well in the air fryer environment.
Final Verdict
For the best air fryer donuts, we recommend investing in an air fryer with a generous capacity and precise temperature control. Models with non-stick, dishwasher-safe baskets are also highly advantageous for easy cleanup. While preset functions are convenient, manual control offers superior flexibility for perfecting your donut recipes. Ultimately, the best air fryer for donuts will allow you to achieve a crisp exterior and a tender interior consistently, making your homemade donut dreams a reality with minimal fuss.